Skip to main content

Society for the Protection of New Hampshire Forests

Get our e-news! Sign up

small nav

  • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Staff
    • Board of Trustees
    • Our History
    • Employment
    • Conservation Center
    • FAQs
    • Partners
    • Business Members
    • Annual Reports
    • Bylaws
    • Policies
  • log in
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

Main menu

  • What we do
    • Land Conservation
    • Education & Events
    • Advocacy
    • Forestry & Recreation
    • News & Features
    • Forest Notes & More Publications
  • Current Projects
    • Mahoosuc Highlands, Shelburne
    • Forest Society North at The Rocks Campaign
    • Build Creek Farm Restrooms, Portsmouth
    • Mount Major Stewardship Fund
    • Recent Accomplishments
  • Visit & Explore
    • The Rocks
    • Conservation Center
    • Mount Major
    • Creek Farm
    • Forest Reservation Guide
    • Visitor Use Guidelines
  • Get Involved
    • Upcoming Events
    • Membership/Renewal
    • Support Our Work
    • Volunteer
    • Subscribe to E-news
    • Annual Meeting 2023
  • Search

Search form

Donate
Menu

News

  • Forest Society Invites Public Comment for LTA Accreditation Renewal

    Naomi Brattlof
    September 20, 2023

    The Forest Society was one of the earliest adopters of these standards.

  • "5 Hikes Challenge" visits Morse Preserve

    Dave Anderson
    September 18, 2023

    It was a beautiful day to check off one of five hikes during the 5 Hikes Challenge.

  • Forestry Friday: The Rare Milkweed Garden at the Gardner Forest

    Sophie Oehler
    September 15, 2023

    In this Forestry Friday, the forestry team takes a trip to the Gardener Forest in Hollis to check in on a population of a rare species of milkweed.

White Mountain National Forest Plan Upheld

February 9, 2009
White Mountain National Forest Plan Upheld

On February 6, 2009 the US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit gave the White Mountain National Forest (WMNF) the legal green light to timber sales that had been challenged by the Sierra Club and The Wilderness Society.

The Appeals Court decision affirmed a lower court ruling issued June 6, 2008 by U S First Circuit Judge Stephen McAuliffe, which upheld a decision by WMNF to proceed with two timber sales, the Than Brook Project in Jackson and the Batchelder Brook Project in Warren.

The Appeals Court ruling reviewed each of the claims raised by the Sierra Club on appeal, dismissing each of them. The Appeals Court ruled that the Forest Service had properly complied with its own forest planning rules, that it had properly complied with the National Forest Management Act, that it had properly complied with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), and that the Sierra Club had failed to establish any legal basis on which the Court could or should stop either the Than or Batchelder Projects.

In addressing the Sierra Club claim that the Forest Service should complete a full Environmental Impact Statement on both projects, the Appeals Court determined that the substantial work done by the Forest Service in preparing comprehensive Environmental Assessments for each project more than complied with the mandate of NEPA to review adverse environmental impacts. One claim made by the Sierra Club was that the effects of both projects were "controversial," thereby requiring a full EIS. The Appeals Court said: "...the highly general character of this claim deprives it of force. We are not told where the controversy lies, or even amongst whom there is a meaningful dispute. As best we can tell, the controversy is that the Sierra Club disagrees with the conclusions the Forest Service reaches, which is not sufficient by itself to warrant an EIS."

This is one victory in a chain of challenges, challenges which have intentionally diverted time and treasure of the professional land managers at the WMNF away from the land and away from the practice of sustainable forest management.

Download the Forest Society Mobile App, powered by OuterSpatial

Available on the App Store
Get it on Google Play

Footer menu

  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
Society for the Protection of New Hampshire Forests54 Portsmouth St.Concord, NH 03301
Phone: 603.224.9945Fax: 603.228.0423info@forestsociety.org
Land Trust Alliance accreditation logo